October 15, 2026

Negligent Security in Montgomery County: When a Property Owner Can Be Held Liable for an Assault in a Parking Garage or Apartment Complex

An assault in a parking garage or apartment complex can leave an injured victim dealing with physical injuries, emotional trauma, medical expenses, and time away from work. In the aftermath of such an attack, it can be easy to focus blame on the individual who committed the assault. But they may not be the only party responsible. If a parking garage or apartment complex was improperly secured, a landlord or property owner may also be responsible for negligent security. 

What is Negligent Security?

Negligent security can arise when a property owner or security provider fails to take reasonable precautions against foreseeable criminal activity, and that failure leads to an individual’s injuries. Under Pennsylvania law, a negligence claim has four elements: (1) a duty of care; (2) a breach of that duty; (3) that the breach caused the injury; and (4) damages. 

Property owners have a duty to take reasonable precautions against known harms. When a property owner knows, or should have known, about a security risk, they must take reasonable steps to address it. If they fail to do so, that can constitute a breach of their duty. This is why foreseeability is crucial in a negligent security claim. A property owner does not have a duty to protect against every crime that might ever occur on their property; that would be an impossible expectation. But when they are aware of foreseeable risks and fail to take precautions against them, liability can arise. 

For example, say an apartment complex is dealing with reports of attempted break-ins, theft, or other crime. If the apartment complex requires a key to be swiped to enter the building for security purposes, and the key swiper breaks, the apartment complex may face liability if an unauthorized person enters the building through that broken door and commits a crime. While the property owner may not be able to prevent every crime, they do have a duty to fix known security issues like a broken key swiper in order to reduce the risk of harm to residents. 

Proving Negligent Security

To bring a negligent security claim, an injured individual must show that a property owner knew, or should have known, about a potential risk to residents or visitors. This type of knowledge can take many forms. In the example above, prior reports to apartment management or the police might establish the property owner’s awareness. A resident may also have reported a concern by email, text, or other means. Evidence to be collected may include:

  • Police reports from prior criminal incidents
  • Photos of security risks, such as inadequate lighting or broken key readers
  • Witness statements from others who observed the risk
  • Communications with staff, management, or other residents related to concerns
  • Security video or surveillance records
  • Internal documents from management such as incident logs or maintenance records

Pennsylvania courts evaluate negligent security using a totality-of-the-circumstances approach, considering what a reasonable property owner would have done under the circumstances. No bright-line rule establishes negligence, as a property owner’s lack ofowner’sguards or a particular security system does not automatically make them responsible for criminal conduct on their property. 

Timely Negligent Security Claims

In the aftermath of an assault, it is natural to want to focus on treatment and your own recovery. But keep in mind that delaying too long could affect your negligent security claim. Proving that a property owner knew or should have known about the risks that led to your harm can be challenging, and much of the evidence you might rely on can be time-sensitive. Surveillance footage may be erased or overwritten within a few weeks, and management may keep incident logs or email communications only for a limited time. 

A Montgomery County premises liability attorney can help locate and preserve important evidence, including requesting relevant documents from agencies and corporations. If you believe there is evidence in your case that you may need to preserve immediately, contacting an attorney to help with this process can be helpful. 

Damages and Negligent Security Claims 

To pursue a negligent security claim, you must show that a property owner’s negligence caused your damages. Damages from an assault claim can include, for example:

  • Ambulance and hospital costs
  • Ongoing medical treatment
  • Physical therapy expenses
  • Mental health treatment
  • Lost wages during recovery
  • Pain and suffering
  • Impact on future wages and opportunities

Proving these damages also requires evidence such as medical bills, treatment records, witness statements, and even medical expert opinions. Depending on the circumstances, an attorney can help you identify the documents you may need to collect. 

Speaking with a Premises Liability Attorney

Understanding your options after an assault or other violent crime can be challenging. While police and prosecutors may focus on the criminal defendant who caused your injuries, you may have to evaluate potential claims against a property owner or security company on your own. Montgomery County premises liability attorney Anthony C. Gagliano III, Esquire, P.C., can help you evaluate the circumstances of your assault, identify potential responsible parties, investigate prior incidents at the same location, and recommend a legal strategy to help you obtain full relief for your injuries. 

If you or someone you love has been assaulted in a Montgomery County parking garage, apartment complex, or other location and you have concerns that inadequate security contributed to the crime that occurred, contact our offices today.